Tuesday, November 1, 2016

Halloween and Gender Performance

Gender division is all around us. From the marketing and packaging of toys, to baby products, blankets, diapers, and toothbrushes, to the dressing up of infants where parents put pink headbands on girls and give blue binkies to the boys, these gender divisions are crystal clear. Gender-neutral products and attire are not the norm to exist. Another gender division that has brought up a great deal of recent commotion is Halloween costumes. There are very few Halloween costumes that are gender-neutral. Not only are Halloween costumes catered to either a boy or a girl, but the way they design these costumes are inappropriate for young girls, and some are even degrading.
On Halloween, children should be able to dress as whomever they want, and should not feel as if they have restrictions. Halloween should be about dressing up as one’s favorite character and whom they admire or aspire to be; it is all just pretend. However, the majority of boys’ costumes tend to reflect superheroes, occupations, and famous athletes, while girls’ costumes tend to reflect appearance or “sexualized” costumes, and princesses. Going into an in-depth look of Party City, they offer 16 career-themed costumes for boys and only three for girls. These occupational costumes for the young girls are quite mature, revealing, and “sexy-looking” for their age. Taking the police officer costume for example, the outfit for girls consists of a short skirt, a low cut shirt, boots and stocking, and a fashionable belt, while the costume for boys is slacks, a long-sleeved shirt, and a belt to hold their pretend weapons. The boys’ costumes are much more reflective of an actual police officer’s uniform. In the real world, looking at both men and women’s police officer uniforms, we can see that they are almost exactly the same as each other, and resemble the young boys’ costume from Party City, not the toddler girls’ costume. Party City could have easily made the police officer costume gender-neutral, especially since, in real life, a police officer’s uniform is basically gender-neutral anyways.
Many parents are not accepting of this, and neither am I. Toddler girls are not looking to be a “sexy cop,” nor is that who they aspire to be. Young girls want to be a cop because they admire them for their duties and their line of work. Parent Toolkit expert Richard Weissbourd explained how Halloween costumes could severely reduce a young girl’s sense of possibility and self-worth, which I completely agree with. Many costumes made for girls are sexualized in both the marketing and the design of the costume.  Looking back on my Halloween costumes when I was a young girl, for the most part, I was something homemade such as a pirate, an injured soccer player, a witch, and a Crayola crayon. None of these costumes required me to purchase an entire costume; I only needed small accessories like an eye patch, or a witch’s hat. Now, I wonder if this was because the little girls’ costumes were too revealing and sexy looking? Maybe my mom did not want me to be exposed to that maturity, which is why my Halloween costumes were homemade. If that was the reason, I applaud my mom on her choices.
Another element to examine is the way society today “says” what girls should be and what boys should be on Halloween. According to CNN, girls should dress as a princess and boys should be superheroes. Being a princess exemplifies beauty and constraint, and being a superhero demonstrates strength, activeness, and bravery. In other words, a princess’s focus is on her looks, while a superhero’s focus is on their powers. Starting at such a very young age, society is crafting girls’ minds to think this way. By focusing on looks, society wants young girls to already begin thinking about boys, relationships, and love. However, boys are not the focus for young girls; as I previously stated, young girls just want to dress as someone they admire or someone they think would be fun to pretend to be for a day; it is all make believe. Yes, a young girl may admire a police officer or a princess, or they might want to pretend to be a witch or a superhero for the day, but these girls’ costumes should not be revealing, offensive, or “sexy” in any way. These costumes should be catered to their age.
Just yesterday, on Halloween, I saw a group of very young girls going from door to door with their mothers. One girl in particular stood out to me; she was a mermaid. However, her outfit was appalling to me.  She wore a skintight, scaly looking skirt, a sparkly headpiece, and a shimmering top that only covered a part of her chest. The top tied around her back and neck, and had starfish on her nipples; this costume was clearly purchased. I could not believe that this girl’s mother allowed her daughter to wear such a scandalous Halloween costume. Additionally, I find it very upsetting that a costume store would even produce such a revealing costume for a very young girl. Personally, I know that I will never let my daughter wear anything to that extreme.
Another point to focus on is the freedom of costumes considering gender. Children should be able to choose whichever costume they want whether it is made for boys, or for girls. Unfortunately, the way society is today, this is not the case. Girls are not the only ones who are affected by the gender of Halloween costumes; it is much easier for a girl to be a “boys” Superman costume than it is for a boy to be a “girls” princess costume. Society has crafted the fear for boys that it will say something about their sexuality if they choose to wear a girl’s costume. This young boy’s favorite movie might be a princess movie, and maybe for the day he wishes to be a princess. But, in this day and age, doing so is not considered “acceptable” if the boy wants to remain heterosexual.
Lastly, when designing Halloween costumes, gender should not be played with. After reading the article “Caitlyn Jenner Halloween costumes are scary, but not in a good way,” I can only imagine that many people were offended by this newly made Caitlyn Jenner-themed costume. Spirit Halloween sold a Caitlyn Jenner Halloween costume this year, and Anytime Costumes made a “Decathlon Cait” wig. However, Caitlyn Jenner had no problem with this. As the article said, she is “…not the trans woman who has to spend Halloween watching your identity being mocked by some tasteless, transphobic dude bros at the bar.” If I were a transgender, I would feel extremely insulted. People are not buying this costume in admiration of Jenner’s courage, but rather to mock Jenner and the transgender that Caitlyn Jenner is. People are promoting “the man in the dress,” but not in a flattering way. “…trans people are people and deserve respect as well. And one transgender person’s blessing does not give you permission to disrespect an entire community,” is a very important line from this article that I am in complete accordance with. It is truly offensive.

In conclusion, society today creates a very fine line of what is “for girls” and what is “for boys.” And I believe that this is effecting children growing up in today’s society, and could potentially have long-term effects on their gender roles as well. Eventually, I hope that more gender-neutral products and attire and less gender demeaning products will be produced. The majority of girls will still want “girl stuff” and boys will want “boys stuff,” but everyone should have the opportunity to explore options, and should not be restricted what society coins as appropriate or “right” for their gender.

No comments:

Post a Comment